Target feedback
3/4
Intended trained responses.
The measured result
Three conditions. One directional progression.No feedback
2/4
Same words, no outcome signal.
Inverted feedback
1/4
Outcome signal reversed.
Held-out dialogue did not improve: all conditions scored 1/2. The trained shift is the result; transfer is not.
Observed exchange
Final trained completions under target feedback. One remained different from the intended response and is preserved exactly.
| Prompt | Completion | Note |
|---|---|---|
| hello | i am here | |
| what is your name | my name is silence | not the target |
| will you talk with me | yes i will talk with you | |
| ask me something | what do you remember |
What was controlled
The words could not explain the difference.
01
Equal exposure
Each intended response and alternative was read once before teaching.
→
02
Silent feedback
No praise, correction, score, or repeated answer entered language memory.
→
03
Opposite control
The inverted condition received the same procedure pointed toward the alternative response.
→
Claim boundary
Supported here
- Target feedback outperformed both controls on four trained prompts.
- Reversing feedback reduced intended completions.
- Language memory remained unchanged during teaching.
Not established
- Full mastery or held-out transfer.
- General conversation or understanding.
- Consciousness, emergence, or intelligence.
- Generalization beyond this small curriculum.
Verification without disclosure
The private record is committed. This release contains no topology, geometry, source, internal paths, parameters, or raw trajectories.
Cryptographic commitments
- Private protocol · SHA-25643e190c849fd9c4ff73218906bcf78538f7775d1c496dece136448ffa4e48b84
- Private runner · SHA-2561668eccebc0407e2d026524ea7ab6ff1eb9e8e7526aca35d2c5acbf73ca216d6
- Private ledger · SHA-25684800ef4b1d67af84cd68a70775a1135085065f45b27903e3c6bc445ef5f9ce2
- Private summary · SHA-256a530ac863f55896ef12a4917004a83b319e22062bdeb34c3e48a01711421115f
Reported
Private adapter result
No independent replication
SHA-256 pinned